|
Value Engineering is
a systematic method to improve the "Value" of goods and services by
using an examination of FUNCTION. Value, as defined, is the ratio of Function
to Cost. Value can therefore be increased by either improving the Function or
reducing the cost. It is a primary tenet of Value Engineering that quality not
be reduced as a consequence of pursuing Value improvements.
Value Engineering uses
intuitive logic (a unique "how" - "why" questioning
technique) and the analysis of Function to identify relationships that
increase Value. It is considered a quantitative method similar to the
Scientific Method, which focuses on Hypothesis - Conclusion to test
relationships, and Operations Research, which uses model building to identify
predictive relationships.
Value
Engineering is often done by systematically following a multi-stage Job Plan.
Larry Miles' original system was a six-step procedure which he called the
Value Analysis Job Plan. Others have varied the Job Plan to fit their
constraints. Depending on the application, there may be four, five, six, or
more stages. One modern version has the following eight steps:
- PREPARATION
- INFORMATION
- ANALYSIS
- CREATION
- EVALUATION
- DEVELOPMENT
- PRESENTATION
- FOLLOW-UP
Four
basic steps in the Job Plan are:
- Information
gathering - This asks what the requirements are for the object. Function
analysis, an important technique in value engineering, is usually done in
this initial stage. It tries to determine what functions or performance
characteristics are important. It asks questions like; What does the
object do? What must it do? What should it do? What could it do? What must
it not do?
- Alternative
generation (Creation) - In this stage value engineers ask; What are the
various alternative ways of meeting requirements? What else will perform
the desired function?
- Evaluation
- In this stage all the alternatives are assessed by evaluating how well
they meet the required functions and how great will the cost savings be.
- Presentation
- In the final stage, the best alternative will be chosen and presented to
the client for final decision.
How
it works
VE
follows a structured thought process to evaluate options. Every VE session
goes through a number of steps:
1.
Gather information What is being done now?
2.
Measure Performance How will the alternatives be measured?
3.
Analyze Functions What must be done? What does it Cost?
4.
Generate Ideas (Brainstorming) What else will do the job?
5.
Evaluate and Rank Ideas Which Ideas are the best?
6.
Develop and Expand Ideas What are the impacts? What is the cost? What is the
performance?
7.
Present Ideas Sell Alternatives
Cost
optimization
Value
engineering reduces costs by eliminating wasteful practices. This can be done
in several areas:
- Material
substitutions - Unnecessarily expensive inputs can sometimes be replaced
by less expensive ones that function just as well. If a product has a life
span of ten years, then using a material that lasts thirty years is
wasteful. In a perfectly value engineered product, every component of that
product will function perfectly until the product is no longer useful, at
which time all components will deteriorate.
- Process
efficiency and producibility - More efficient processes can be used and
the product can be redesigned so that it is easier to produce. Reducing
unnecessary parts, unnecessary precision, and unnecessary production
operations can lower costs and increase manufacturability, reliability,
and profits. Process engineering can be used to increase process
efficiency.
- Modularity
- Subassemblies that are designed and developed once and reused in many
slightly different products can reduce a project's engineering and design
costs. For example, a typical tape-player has a precision injection-molded
tape-deck compartment. This component can be produced, assembled and
tested by an independent manufacturer and sold to numerous companies as a
subassembly. The tooling and design expense for the tape deck is shared
over many products that can look quite different.
- Market
driven product improvements - A product with more features than customers
want is inefficient. Customers will be paying for features that they
don’t want to pay for. Value engineering can determine how to produce a
product that exactly matches the wants of a major segment of the market.
When a customer needs more features, these can be sold as options.
- Energy
efficiency - Value can be created by making a product or process more
energy efficient for the user. This is particularly true in heating and
air conditioning systems, transportation vehicles, industrial equipment,
and other systems that use much energy.
When
value engineers talk about reducing costs, they are usually referring to
either total life cycle costs or the direct costs of production. Total life
cycle costs are the total expenditures over the whole life span of the
product. This measure of cost is most applicable to expensive capital
equipment, and includes manufacturing costs, installation costs, maintenance
costs, and decommissioning costs. Individual expenditures must be discounted
to reflect the time value of money. When referring to consumer products, the
direct cost of production is more typically used. This measure is limited to
the costs directly associated with manufacturing the product.
Examples
of value engineering
- Russian
liquid-fuel rocket motors are intentionally designed to permit ugly
(though leak-free) welding. This reduces costs by eliminating grinding and
finishing operations that do not help the motor function better.
- Some
Japanese disc brakes have parts toleranced to three millimeters, an
easy-to-meet precision. When combined with crude statistical process
controls, this assures that less than one in a million parts will fail to
fit.
- Many
vehicle manufacturers have active programs to reduce the numbers and types
of fasteners in their product, to reduce inventory, tooling and assembly
costs.
- Often
a premium forming process (like "near net shape" forming) can
eliminate hundreds of low-precision machining or drilling steps. Precision
transfer stamping can quickly produce hundreds of high quality parts from
generic rolls of steel and aluminum. Die casting is used to produce metal
parts from aluminum or sturdy tin alloys (they're often about as strong as
mild steels). Plastic injection molding is a powerful technique,
especially if the part's special properties are supplemented with inserts
of brass or steel.
- When
a product incorporates a computer, it replaces many parts with software
that fits into a single light-weight, low-power memory part or
microcontroller. As computers grow faster, digital signal processing
software is beginning to replace many analog electronic circuits for audio
and sometimes radio frequency processing.
- On
some printed circuit boards (itself a producibility technique), the
conductors are intentionally sized to act as delay lines, resistors and
inductors to reduce the parts count. An important recent innovation was to
eliminate the leads of "surface mounted" components. In one
stroke, this eliminated the need to drill most holes in a printed circuit
board, as well as clip off the leads after soldering.
- In
Japan (the land where manufacturing engineers are most valued), it is a
standard process to design printed circuit boards of inexpensive phenolic
resin and paper, and reduce the number of copper layers to one or two to
lower costs without harming specifications.
- In
a U.S. environmental species restoration for the Black Footed Ferret, a
value study using recent VEVA tools enable the species to be
re-established more effectively, and with less chance of harm to the
animals (VEReporting).
|